Low-res many-view results

This table lists the benchmark results for the low-res many-view scenario. The following metrics are evaluated:

Accuracy [%]: The fraction of the reconstruction which is closer to the ground truth than the evaluation threshold distance (*). Larger is better.
Completeness [%]: The fraction of the ground truth which is closer to the reconstruction than the evaluation threshold distance (*). Larger is better.
F₁ score [%]: The harmonic mean of accuracy and completeness, used to rank methods based on both metrics. Larger is better.
Time [s]: The runtime of the method. Smaller is better.

(*) For exact definitions, detailing how potentially incomplete ground truth is taken into account, see our paper.

The datasets are grouped into different categories, and result averages are computed for a category and method if results of the method are available for all datasets within the category. Note that the category "all" includes both the high-res multi-view and the low-res many-view scenarios.

Methods with suffix _ROB may participate in the Robust Vision Challenge.

Click a dataset result cell to show a visualization of the reconstruction. For training datasets, ground truth and accuracy / completeness visualizations are also available. The visualizations may not work with mobile browsers.

Method	all	low-res many-view	indoor	outdoor	lakeside	sand box	storage room	storage room 2	tunnel

DeepC-MVS	69.38 2	47.34 1	38.25 1	53.40 2	54.29 4	56.62 3	32.95 1	43.55 2	49.30 3
Andreas Kuhn, Christian Sormann, Mattia Rossi, Oliver Erdler, Friedrich Fraundorfer: DeepC-MVS: Deep Confidence Prediction for Multi-View Stereo Reconstruction. 3DV 2020
TAPA-MVS	59.36 10	41.97 9	37.54 2	44.93 15	46.78 16	46.52 19	31.44 3	43.65 1	41.48 16
Andrea Romanoni, Matteo Matteucci: TAPA-MVS: Textureless-Aware PAtchMatch Multi-View Stereo. ICCV 2019
DeepPCF-MVS	69.58 1	46.90 2	37.52 3	53.15 3	53.58 5	57.05 2	32.83 2	42.22 3	48.83 5

DeepC-MVS_fast	68.24 3	46.61 3	34.94 4	54.40 1	55.37 3	57.55 1	31.02 4	38.86 4	50.28 1
Andreas Kuhn, Christian Sormann, Mattia Rossi, Oliver Erdler, Friedrich Fraundorfer: DeepC-MVS: Deep Confidence Prediction for Multi-View Stereo Reconstruction. 3DV 2020
3Dnovator	64.47 5	45.24 4	34.37 5	52.48 5	57.34 1	53.53 5	30.63 5	38.11 6	46.56 9

PCF-MVS	61.88 8	40.12 13	33.16 6	44.75 16	49.39 10	46.16 20	28.63 7	37.70 7	38.70 25
Andreas Kuhn, Shan Lin, Oliver Erdler: Plane Completion and Filtering for Multi-View Stereo Reconstruction. GCPR 2019
3Dnovator+	66.72 4	44.84 5	33.14 7	52.63 4	56.23 2	53.78 4	29.20 6	37.07 10	47.89 6

OpenMVS	61.03 9	42.28 7	32.86 8	48.56 10	51.94 7	50.82 10	27.02 9	38.70 5	42.92 13

tm-dncc		42.17 8	31.89 9	49.03 7	49.63 8	50.53 11	26.59 12	37.19 9	46.92 8

ACMP	63.53 6	42.50 6	31.11 10	50.08 6	48.62 12	52.78 7	24.90 18	37.33 8	48.84 4
Qingshan Xu and Wenbing Tao: Planar Prior Assisted PatchMatch Multi-View Stereo. AAAI 2020
COLMAP(SR)		41.20 10	29.58 11	48.95 8	48.70 11	48.18 14	28.26 8	30.89 19	49.98 2

TAPA-MVS(SR)		40.72 12	29.34 12	48.31 11	52.32 6	44.77 24	26.63 11	32.05 14	47.84 7

ACMM	61.98 7	40.80 11	29.05 13	48.64 9	46.87 14	53.22 6	23.47 22	34.63 11	45.82 10
Qingshan Xu and Wenbing Tao: Multi-Scale Geometric Consistency Guided Multi-View Stereo. CVPR 2019
ACMH+	57.40 11	36.48 17	28.86 14	41.57 24	43.89 22	37.61 38	26.39 14	31.33 17	43.20 12

PLC	56.13 14	34.63 24	28.70 15	38.59 33	36.78 38	44.65 25	26.03 15	31.36 16	34.33 35
Jie Liao, Yanping Fu, Qingan Yan, Chunxia xiao: Pyramid Multi-View Stereo with Local Consistency. Pacific Graphics 2019
LTVRE_ROB	55.42 16	36.88 16	28.57 16	42.42 22	40.72 30	48.22 13	26.97 10	30.17 21	38.32 26
Andreas Kuhn, Heiko HirschmÃ¼ller, Daniel Scharstein, Helmut Mayer: A TV Prior for High-Quality Scalable Multi-View Stereo Reconstruction. International Journal of Computer Vision 2016
HY-MVS	56.14 13	35.94 18	28.51 17	40.89 25	43.99 21	38.59 36	25.07 16	31.96 15	40.09 20

AttMVS		34.35 25	28.45 18	38.28 34	40.03 31	40.06 30	23.67 20	33.23 12	34.75 34

IB-MVS	56.42 12	34.86 22	28.22 19	39.29 30	43.59 23	38.19 37	23.59 21	32.85 13	36.09 32
Christian Sormann, Mattia Rossi, Andreas Kuhn and Friedrich Fraundorfer: IB-MVS: An Iterative Algorithm for Deep Multi-View Stereo based on Binary Decisions. BMVC 2021
COLMAP(base)		37.35 15	28.09 20	43.52 18	42.34 24	46.68 18	26.55 13	29.63 22	41.53 15

OpenMVS_ROB	52.78 18	35.39 20	27.98 21	40.33 26	46.81 15	36.10 44	24.79 19	31.17 18	38.08 27

tmmvs		38.38 14	26.53 22	46.29 14	49.63 8	50.53 11	25.02 17	28.03 23	38.71 24

CIDER		32.55 34	25.75 23	37.08 38	39.65 32	40.58 29	20.91 29	30.59 20	31.00 40
Qingshan Xu and Wenbing Tao: Learning Inverse Depth Regression for Multi-View Stereo with Correlation Cost Volume. AAAI 2020
COLMAP_ROB	52.97 17	33.06 31	25.38 24	38.18 35	35.81 40	45.04 23	22.92 26	27.84 25	33.69 36
Johannes L. SchÃ¶nberger, Enliang Zheng, Marc Pollefeys, Jan-Michael Frahm: Pixelwise View Selection for Unstructured Multi-View Stereo. ECCV 2016
LPCS		33.63 28	24.80 25	39.52 28	42.29 25	39.01 34	23.44 23	26.15 28	37.27 29

PVSNet	50.76 19	32.44 35	24.74 26	37.57 37	38.43 35	36.66 43	23.03 25	26.46 27	37.62 28

PVSNet_0	43.31 20	33.35 29	23.83 27	39.69 27	41.22 28	38.75 35	21.08 28	26.59 26	39.10 23

ACMH	55.70 15	32.91 32	23.69 28	39.06 31	41.22 28	36.76 42	21.84 27	25.54 29	39.18 22
Qingshan Xu and Wenbing Tao: Multi-Scale Geometric Consistency Guided Multi-View Stereo. CVPR 2019
GSE		34.79 23	23.63 29	42.23 23	46.31 17	39.18 33	23.20 24	24.07 32	41.20 17

PVSNet_LR		34.22 26	21.35 30	42.80 21	42.24 26	45.98 21	14.83 39	27.87 24	40.18 19

P-MVSNet		29.35 38	20.98 31	34.93 40	34.55 44	36.99 40	20.06 30	21.91 39	33.25 38

BP-MVSNet		29.92 37	20.53 32	36.17 39	37.89 36	33.68 49	17.55 32	23.52 36	36.95 30
Christian Sormann, Patrick KnÃ¶belreiter, Andreas Kuhn, Mattia Rossi, Thomas Pock, Friedrich Fraundorfer: BP-MVSNet: Belief-Propagation-Layers for Multi-View-Stereo. 3DV 2020
CasMVSNet(SR_B)		23.80 46	19.79 33	26.47 50	24.88 50	37.51 39	14.94 38	24.65 30	17.01 52

mvs_zhu_1030		33.71 27	19.38 34	43.27 19	42.20 27	47.82 16	15.18 37	23.58 34	39.77 21

CasMVSNet(SR_A)		35.87 19	19.38 34	46.87 12	46.17 18	51.96 9	14.32 41	24.45 31	42.47 14

test_1205		28.37 40	19.29 36	34.43 41	34.50 45	41.99 28	15.81 34	22.78 37	26.79 45

MVSNet		27.45 42	18.54 37	33.39 43	29.32 47	47.13 17	13.18 43	23.89 33	23.72 46

CasMVSNet(base)		35.32 21	18.44 38	46.56 13	46.00 20	52.64 8	13.32 42	23.57 35	41.04 18

R-MVSNet		23.84 45	18.30 39	27.54 47	27.82 48	33.79 48	14.57 40	22.03 38	21.00 50

test_1126		33.11 30	18.21 40	43.04 20	47.43 13	45.33 22	15.33 36	21.10 40	36.35 31

A-TVSNet + Gipuma		26.68 43	16.93 41	33.18 44	31.29 46	39.82 32	17.28 33	16.57 47	28.43 43

ANet		30.02 36	16.73 42	38.88 32	39.32 33	44.06 26	15.61 35	17.85 43	33.26 37

Pnet-new-		32.65 33	16.09 43	43.68 17	46.15 19	39.98 31	18.51 31	13.67 55	44.91 11

CPR_FA		14.43 57	14.90 44	14.12 65	11.38 62	14.82 68	11.91 45	17.89 42	16.15 58

A1Net		14.51 56	14.40 45	14.59 58	13.30 59	12.51 70	11.95 44	16.85 45	17.96 51

ANet-0.75		29.06 39	13.44 46	39.47 29	39.32 33	44.06 26	10.78 47	16.11 49	35.02 33

unsupervisedMVS_cas		21.41 49	13.42 47	26.73 49	25.53 49	31.05 52	10.34 48	16.50 48	23.60 47

Pnet_fast		27.80 41	12.25 48	38.17 36	37.73 37	47.91 15	7.47 62	17.03 44	28.88 42

MVSCRF		18.49 51	12.01 49	22.81 52	20.51 55	32.84 50	9.61 49	14.41 54	15.08 62

Snet		16.01 53	11.97 50	18.70 54	22.09 53	17.12 59	8.46 55	15.48 51	16.90 55

test3		13.22 59	11.25 51	14.54 59	11.46 61	17.02 60	9.59 50	12.91 57	15.13 60

MVS_test_1		15.08 55	10.97 52	17.82 55	23.84 51	16.69 61	5.32 70	16.61 46	12.93 63

TVSNet		13.02 60	10.86 53	14.46 61	11.60 60	16.67 62	8.79 53	12.93 56	15.10 61

Pnet-eth		8.45 75	10.49 54	7.10 78	9.98 72	2.92 83	5.14 71	15.84 50	8.40 72

MVSNet_++		16.58 52	10.34 55	20.75 53	22.25 52	11.60 72	1.64 83	19.05 41	28.39 44

SGNet		11.73 64	9.85 56	12.98 66	10.55 68	15.85 64	8.23 57	11.47 58	12.53 64

MVE	17.77 23	9.03 74	9.66 57	8.62 75	6.03 78	11.40 74	8.30 56	11.02 59	8.42 71
Simon Fuhrmann, Fabian Langguth, Michael Goesele: MVE - A Multi-View Reconstruction Environment. EUROGRAPHICS Workshops on Graphics and Cultural Heritage (2014)
QQQNet		12.59 61	9.43 58	14.70 57	10.88 66	16.24 63	8.64 54	10.22 61	16.97 53

PSD-MVSNet		11.22 65	9.34 59	12.48 67	10.37 69	15.20 67	7.81 61	10.86 60	11.87 65

SVVNet		12.22 62	9.22 60	14.22 63	10.32 70	15.62 65	8.22 58	10.22 61	16.70 56

ternet		12.22 62	9.22 60	14.22 63	10.32 70	15.62 65	8.22 58	10.22 61	16.70 56

Pnet-blend++		21.89 47	9.21 62	30.34 45	34.58 42	34.44 45	3.76 76	14.67 52	22.00 48

Pnet-blend		21.89 47	9.21 62	30.34 45	34.58 42	34.44 45	3.76 76	14.67 52	22.00 48

test_1124		23.88 44	8.92 64	33.86 42	35.80 41	36.79 41	10.99 46	6.84 72	28.99 41

F/T MVSNet+Gipuma		9.78 68	8.13 65	10.88 73	9.23 73	11.92 71	8.81 51	7.45 70	11.49 66

MVSNet + Gipuma		9.47 71	7.91 66	10.52 74	8.91 75	11.46 73	8.80 52	7.01 71	11.18 69

CCVNet		13.25 58	7.81 67	16.88 56	13.52 57	20.14 55	7.96 60	7.67 69	16.97 53

RMVSNet		4.93 80	7.73 68	3.06 82	3.93 80	3.22 82	5.95 69	9.52 65	2.04 81

firsttry		9.57 69	7.40 69	11.02 72	11.05 63	10.54 75	6.97 65	7.82 68	11.49 66

metmvs_fine		4.94 79	7.02 70	3.56 81	3.18 82	3.86 80	4.62 73	9.43 66	3.63 75

MVSNet_plusplus		19.10 50	6.64 71	27.41 48	36.63 39	14.19 69	3.12 79	10.15 64	31.41 39

hgnet		9.31 72	6.52 72	11.17 70	10.91 64	20.13 56	7.15 63	5.89 73	2.47 79

DPSNet		9.31 72	6.52 72	11.17 70	10.91 64	20.13 56	7.15 63	5.89 73	2.47 79

unMVSv1		6.85 76	6.06 74	7.37 77	7.56 76	9.33 76	6.35 68	5.76 75	5.22 74

test_mvsss		11.00 66	6.00 75	14.32 62	13.56 56	19.16 58	4.03 75	7.98 67	10.25 70

example		9.54 70	5.97 76	11.92 68	13.40 58	20.72 54	6.89 66	5.05 76	1.63 82

PMVS	28.69 22	10.60 67	4.70 77	14.53 60	10.82 67	30.05 53	6.66 67	2.74 78	2.71 77
Y. Furukawa, J. Ponce: Accurate, dense, and robust multiview stereopsis. PAMI (2010)
test_1120		6.40 78	4.10 78	7.94 76	6.69 77	5.86 78	4.95 72	3.26 77	11.26 68

vp_mvsnet		15.26 54	2.83 79	23.55 51	21.00 54	34.21 47	3.45 78	2.22 79	15.43 59

unMVSmet		3.60 82	2.44 80	4.38 80	3.82 81	6.35 77	2.69 81	2.18 80	2.97 76

Cas-MVS_preliminary		4.12 81	1.79 81	5.67 79	4.49 79	4.19 79	2.85 80	0.74 82	8.32 73

confMetMVS		2.34 83	1.33 82	3.02 83	3.03 83	3.47 81	1.14 84	1.52 81	2.56 78

FADENet		0.06 84	0.04 83	0.07 85	0.12 86	0.08 85	0.05 85	0.03 83	0.02 84

CMPMVS	42.80 21	6.77 77	0.01 84	11.27 69	1.93 85	31.86 51	0.03 86	0.00 84	0.00 85
M. Jancosek, T. Pajdla: Multi-View Reconstruction Preserving Weakly-Supported Surfaces. CVPR 2011
dnet		0.00 85	0.00 85	0.00 86	0.00 87	0.00 86	0.00 87	0.00 84	0.00 85

test_MVS							4.13 74

test_robustmvs				1.65 84	2.89 84	1.35 84	2.69 81		0.72 83

UnsupFinetunedMVSNet					9.23 73

Low-resolution many-view benchmark